Here and there, I’ve noticed and heard comments from people that the circus which has erupted from the Terri Schiavo case would never have happened in Europe. And they are correct, although not for the reasons that they thought.
Europe, or at least certain nations, do have a very different view of life and death, particularly when it comes to end-of-life-issues. But for those who think that the Terri Schiavo case would be a no-brainer in Europe, that the woman’s feeding tube would be “compassionately” removed and she would be allowed to die, think again. If Terri lived in a country such as Belgium or Germany, rest assured, she would be settled quietly in bed, her feeding tube snugly in place, and nourishment and fluids flowing through it.
The Netherlands, Switzerland and Belgium allow physician-assisted death in various incarnations. About 2,000 people die through assistance from their doctor each year in the Netherlands alone. But Terri Schiavo would most definitely not be among them.
You see, these nations do not take death lightly, regardless of the way it is often perceived over here. There has to be a firm directive from the patient, made while they were mentally competent, that they choose to die. The same is true for withholding care, such as a feeding tube. The type of half-baked statement which emanated from the mouth of Terri’s estranged husband (yes, a man living with another woman and fathering two kids with her is estranged) several years after her collapse–that he didn’t think that “Terri would want to live like this,” simply wouldn’t make the grade. A patient in Europe would not be starved to death based on such a feeble argument. And especially, when there is such vehement opposition from parents and siblings.
From Deutche Welle: Dutch laws, like those in Switzerland and Belgium, require that the patient clearly and insistently request death. Schiavo, had she ever requested death should she fall into a vegetative state, did not insist on it. For this reason, even relatively socially liberal groups, like the Union of Protestant Churches in Germany, or the German Medical Association, have not recommended removing Schiavo’s feeding tube.
“The patient’s doctors are required to continue to treat her and to feed her, because it’s not clear what will happen next with her illness,” said Jörg-Dietrich Hoppe, the head of the German Medical Association.
Hoppe said there have been cases “of people who lived for 20 years in a ‘waking coma’ and then later came back to consciousness. The patient is certainly not dead.”
So in many ways, even though some think that the euthanasia laws in Europe are “immoral” and that they have no respect for life, it seems that they have a great deal more respect for life than we do. That a patient such as Terri would never be put in this position, that no one will ever be denied care unless there is absolute certainty that this is what they wanted.
I think we have a great deal to learn from “Old Europe.”