Nursing shortage to get worse
Dropout rates increase for student nurses.
Aggravating California’s critical nursing shortage, nearly a quarter of all students studying to be nurses in Los Angeles community colleges dropped out in 2003-04 more than 35 percent higher than the statewide average.
College officials say the drop-out rate is so high that it is becoming one of the most significant bottlenecks in an already-strained system that produces two-thirds of the state’s nurses.
This is from the Press Telegram, a newspaper published in Southern California. The article has that attitude of “shock,” like “I just thought that all we needed to do was bolster the ranks in nursing schools.”
From the eyes of all of the experts, the great nursing shortage of the 21st century stems from a lack of nurses entering the profession, not a mass revolt bolting from it. The simple pin-headed logic (which doesn’t force hospitals and other facilities to take any of the blame or make any changes in the way they do business) is to entice more people into nursing. They figure that once they’ve got these people warming seats in the classroom, the problem is over.
According to the article, the solution for the high rate of attrition is to push for tighter admissions standards that “would help prevent unprepared applicants from ever entering the system.”
The high dropout rates in the community colleges were blamed primarily on the fact that students often juggle the demands of full-time jobs and family duties. Other students struggle with English, or find themselves under-prepared for the demanding courses.
It is really pathetic, but even in a situation like this, they just can’t acknowledge what is really going on. If the true reasons were the ones given above, ie, struggle with English and family demands, then you would see drop out rates across the board. Nursing is time consuming, but most people drop out before they get very far in the clinicals, which are the most time intensive. What you would see is a drop out rate among people taking demanding majors, science courses and so, across the board.
Sorry, guys, but the drop out rate has another reason. Not only are many of these students ill-prepared, they also haven’t a clue as to what nursing actually is about. Thanks to the mass advertising campaigns, such as the moronic Discover Nursing by Johnson & Johnson, nursing is being touted as this slick and sophisticated career, that “anyone” can do. Yes, the ads basically tell you that “you can be a nurse.”
Cool. Now let’s hear another fairy tale.
While I shudder when I hear of nursing being referred to as a “calling,” in the mode of Florence Nightingale, it is also not a job for everyone. But yet, nursing has been held out like a carrot to a hungry rabbit–millions of hungry rabbits, in fact–who were laid off from jobs at the turn of the millennium.
Sorry pal, but switching from being a computer programmer to a nurse is just a little bit different than switching to accounting, or even becoming a pharmacist. But nursing is presented as this sophisticated, clean, well-paying profession with endless possibilities. The sparkling faces profiled in Discover Nursing never tell you what they actually do, only that they “help people.” They never go into detail, and try to keep quiet about what their job might actually entail.
Of course, anyone with half a brain would wonder, “If nursing is as great as these ads claim, then why the big shortage? Why aren’t there enough nurses?”
The advertising and spoon-fed media try to work around that by talking about the nursing shortage as though its simply a matter of an aging nursing population, and that other jobs attract younger people. Of course, you still have to wonder again, “If nursing is so great, then why can’t it hold its own with other professions? Why aren’t young people going into nursing?”
The high rate of attrition is primarily caused by two things. One is that once in the program, when people find out exactly what nursing is about, and see the actual working conditions in many of the hospitals, they’re outta here. This is not the glorious career they were promised–hmmm, nothing was ever said in the ads about nurses pulling trash and linens, working mandatory overtime, and being cursed out by a patient (with admin taking the side of the patient and disciplining the nurse).
Yes, once they see what nursing is really about, and the hard physical job that it is, they quit.
The second reason is that many nursing instructors are power hungry assholes, who delight in making nursing students quiver in their boots, and in making them feel like morons. This has been going on since Florence Nightingale’s time. Some instructors feel like they have complete power over their students and they revel in it. I suppose it’s something like the female version of the guy who thinks his dick is too short, and tries to make up for it by being cruel and sadistic to those under his thumb.
And since teachers are in such short supply, the nursing school hierarchy tends to support the teacher, regardless of how they treat their students. I’ve heard of teachers flunking students they simply didn’t like, or who refused to kiss their ass. Students who were quite capable. But clinical rotations are very subjective, so it’s the student’s word against the teacher, and guess who the school usually sides with?
So again, we have students who are intimidated and leave, those who refuse to be pushed around by some crazed bitch, and so on.
But this article doesn’t mention any of these reasons. Again, fantasy reporting at its best.
Anecdotally, some students are reporting attrition rates as high as 60% in their programs, and not just in community colleges. The drop-out rate in nursing programs nationwide, and in both four and two year colleges, is high. Thanks, in part, to Johnson & Johnson. And to all those who think that the nursing shortage can be solved merely by polishing the image of the nurse on paper and on celluloid.
I love how this article calls the drop-out rate a “bottleneck.” And one of the most “significant bottlenecks.” It seems so shocked that students would dare to drop out of nursing school, but in reality, nursing programs have always had high attrition rates. Some higher than others, but it’s always been a fact of nursing education. Back in the good old days, when women didn’t have much of a choice of careers, many stayed and put up with the demeaning garbage delivered to them during their training. But the times have changed.