A lot of nurses (and I don’t say ALL nurses because not every nurse feels this way–RN or LPN after a name does not make one caring and compassionate regardless of the stereotype) are concerned about the 40-60 million people who do not have health insurance in this country. Or
the ones that are underinsured.
As a new year’s resolution, some California politicos would like to change that. Bravo, I say, except they are going about it in a completely anal and stupid manner. Oh, it looks good on paper, but it just can’t work in reality. Why won’t it work? Because the politicos are looking at the usual bandaid approach and not tackling the situation at the heart.
Insurance companies. They slip by these proposals with nary a mention. Not a word about the exorbitant overpricing, not a word about the piddly policies pushed on people, not a word about cutting people off if they ever should get sick.
From the San Francisco Chronicle:
Second Democrat puts forth health care overhaul plan — focus on kids
Sacramento, CA — A new health care overhaul proposal released Thursday by the leader of the state Assembly would extend insurance to all Californians by mandating that employers pay for coverage and by expanding existing government programs for the poor and disabled.
But Assembly Speaker Fabian Núñez, D-Los Angeles, said his primary goal is to make sure that all children in the state — including illegal immigrants — are provided insurance coverage.
“First and foremost, what this is about are the kids,” said Núñez at a news conference held in the children’s clinic at the UC Davis Medical Center in Sacramento. “You cannot have health care reform unless each and every child in the state of California is covered. So above everything else, children need to get the health care they deserve.”
Sorry, but I’m not that much of a bleeding heart liberal. Illegal immigrants have no business getting one iota of public funding. That’s a great incentive to curtail illegals from crossing the border, isn’t it. Just get the word out that if they can manage to make it to California, they will be eligible for publically funded healthcare.
Yes, Fabian, we can have health reform without paying medical expenses of illegal immigrants. We should be deporting them, not pouring money into making them comfortable here. If they want to emigrate to the US, then let them do so through legal official channels, as other immigrants. And why they arrive here LEGALLY, get legal resident status, then they can be inlcuded in whatever plan is cooked up.
But here’s a few other intelligent tidbits, which are guaranteed not to work.
Both Perata and Núñez want to require employers to pay for worker coverage and are unlikely to settle for any voluntary program.
Both also want workers to share some of the costs with their employers, but neither has said how those costs should be divided. Expectations are that Democrats will want to put the lion’s share of the burden on employers.
Mr. Nunez is willing to “provide a temporary exemption to payment requirements for employers with fewer than two full-time employees.”
Wow, isnt’ that generous of him. But you can see that the man is so out of touch with reality, or maybe deeply enmeshed in the pockets of the insurance companies.
First, most small mom and pop businesses can’t afford to provide insurance to employees. Insuance companies have seen to that, and offer very little in the way of discounts for the small business owners. So in keeping in step with Fabian’s brilliant plan, we will see 1) small businesses laying off employees because they can’t afford to insure them 2) Small businesses going out of business 3) A lot more people getting pushed to part time (sans benefits) or per diem, or contractor status. In other words, they will search for ways to get around this hideous tax on them.
You see, what is missing from all this is any word about insurance reform. There is nothing in Fabian’s brilliant plan about reigning in insurance costs, forcing insurers to come up with affordable packages for small businesses, or forcing them to offer more comprehensive coverage. So you really have to wonder about someone like Fabian, who has so delicately left out any mention of the primary cause of the problem–costs that people can’t afford.
Bottom line–no health reform bill is going to make any difference until someone gets the balls to face off with the insurance companies.
Vince Sollitto, spokesman for the California Chamber of Commerce, said the mandate on employers will be viewed as a tax — and one that many cannot pay.
“The problem with a tax is that it presumes the ability to pay it,” he said. “If employers could pay it, they would already be providing health insurance to their employees. The reason they don’t is that they can’t afford it.”
At least there is one intelligent voice in California. But now, is anyone in the California government, including the governator, going to take on the insurance industry?