George Bush just keeps on giving. The man is history, and has exactly 1 month and day left as president in this country. But you know, its Christmas, and GWB is the gift that just keeps on giving.
His latest idiocy and insult to this country is the “conscience law” which allow health care providers to refuse to dole out treatment that is contrary to their conscience. The major problem with this law is that it is so broad that virtually anyone working in health care can invoke it. For example, a receptionist who feels that sterilization is morally wrong can refuse to schedule an appointment for a man to get a vasectomy. A nursing assistant can refuse to give a bedbath to a gay man, or change his bedpan if she feels that homosexuality is wrong and the man is a sinner and doesn’t deserve to be cared for.
The list is endless. But what is missing from this scenario is the patient. Healthcare is supposed to evolve around the patient, not the provider. If you work in healthcare, you better get used to people coming at you from all walks of life.
When I worked in the NICU, we had many families that made my flesh crawl. Like the 27 year old woman with a 14 year old daughter giving birth to her 10th kid. All with different fathers, on welfare–well, you get the picture. I’d personally like to snip her tubes, but the best we could do was counsel her, and take care of her baby. Get social services involved to make sure that the baby whose life we worked so hard to save would be cared for.
From USA Today:
Under the rule, which takes effect mid-January, anyone from the brain surgeon to the pharmacy cashier can opt out of participating in care to which they have a moral or religious objection. Health and Human Services Secretary Michael Leavitt described it as a rule to protect “the right of medical providers to care for their patients in accord with their conscience.”
The Family Research Council calls the rule “an early Christmas present to pro-lifers” which will “reinforce the rights of doctors, pharmacists, technicians, and even receptionists …
Protecting the right of all health care providers to make professional judgments based on their moral convictions is foundational to federal law. The next administration will inherit these rules, and we strongly urge President-elect Obama to defend them. True tolerance would allow the choice of conscience to be defined by individuals — not the government.
Are these people daft or what? Health care providers are supposed to make decisions based on standard practice, science, and the needs/wants of the patient. Not their moral convictions, which should play no part in any healthcare decision making because they can be in direct conflict with what the patient wants.
Well the Family Research Council must be drinking spiked Kool-Aid if they think that Obama is going to defend this assault on healthcare. Hopefully Congress will block it immediately, so that Obama doesn’t have to deal with it. Senators Clinton and Murray have already introduced a bill to repeal it.
Women seeing reproductive health care, gay individuals and couples dealing with emergencies or even routine treatment, even people who see vaccines or antibiotics for their babies will face health care roulette on all fronts. Who knows the beliefs of the triage nurse in the ER?
What the defenders of this law don’t realize is that it can affect them. Their brain is focused on abortion or emergency contraception, but little do they know that they can be a victim of moral conscience. Gee, what if a nurse invokes her Jehovah Witness status and refuses to give them blood? Maybe they can bleed to death? Or if the pharmacist refuses to fill their prescription for a drug he considers “objectionable” such as a painkiller, and he’s the only open one in town. Tough luck, kiddo, you’ll have to suffer all night.
People who are carrying around too much moral baggage should not be working in health care, or at least, choose a niche where it won’t be a problem.
Under this law, even a cashier can refuse to ring you up, if they don’t like what you’re buying. Gee, they think deodorant is immoral, hiding the natural scent that God gave you. Oh my, you should not be buying tampons–how icky.

Merry Christmas, George Bush. How about giving the nation a present and resigning now? Just remember, what goes around comes around. Wait until you’re sick, and the health care team refuses to care for you, saying that it is against their conscience to care for a mass murderer….
Photo courtesy of Clipartguide.com