Most renditions of healthcare on television are fairly pathetic. Even simple things that could be done correctly, without any added cost or airtime, are messed up. Do the medical advisers who are supposedly advising just not advising, or are the powers that be just not listening? Or both?
A survey from Medpage.com had some interesting results and responses. Nearly all respondents said that prime time medical TV shows have an impact on the doctor-patient relationship, for better or worse. While they didn’t give a break-down of which were best shows vs. worst shows, they did offer varying comments. It would be interesting to see a large survey from healthcare workers, which gives an actual breakdwon on which shows they think are the worst, the best, the most unrealistic, etc.
But some of the Medpage comments were as follows:
- “Scrubs has the best portrayal of nurses. Also, the only show that gets it right on type 2 diabetes.”
- “As a medical technologist, I am very disappointed that the laboratory is ignored in most medical shows. In real life, most doctors wouldn’t know the first thing about how to crossmatch a unit or do a CBC or lipid profile.”
- “Frazier was the best show with the worst portrayal of psychiatry ever. I once had a patient ask me during an initial eval if I, or anyone else in my practice, did ‘ . . . what Dr. Phil does.’ I think that about says it all.”
- “I think a show like St. Elsewhere gave an inkling of what a city hospital is like as a reality check.”
- “I don’t know who teaches these actors how to play the role of a doctor but they do a horrible job.”
I agree with most of it (haven’t seen Scrubs so can’t comment). But really, most of these shows portray the physician as also being nurse, lab tech, ultrasound tech, radiology tech, housekeeper, and as having all the time in the world to sit and chitchat and solve a life time of issues with the patient.
I really did like St. Elsewhere. Yeah, there was the usual romance and the nasty stereotype big shot doc, but the show was realistic in many ways. Better than most.
